Basket maths, attach rate, choosing the product, stock, the rules on selling below cost and bait offers, and how to measure the effect of a loss leader.

In almost every Black Friday or Christmas campaign the idea comes up: "let's put one product at a really low price to bring people to the site". Sometimes it works very well. Other times the store sells hundreds of units at close to zero margin, pays shipping on every one and finds out at the end that people bought only the cheap product. The difference comes down to one thing: how much customers add to the basket next to the loss leader. Below I show how to do the maths, how to choose the product, how to handle stock, what the rules in Romania and Denmark say about selling below cost and bait offers, and how to measure the effect after the campaign. At the end there's a calculator that compares a loss leader campaign with your usual offer.
A loss leader is a product sold at a very attractive price, with a thin margin, to bring in orders where the customer also buys other products at a normal margin. The profit doesn't come from the loss leader, it comes from the rest of the basket.
It works when three conditions hold at the same time: the price is easy to recognise as a good deal, the product has natural companions in your store, and shipping cost doesn't eat everything you earn on the rest of the basket. If one is missing, you just have a big discount under another name.
The profit of an order with a loss leader has four parts: the margin on the loss leader, which can be very small, plus the profit on the added products, minus the variable cost of the order (shipping, packaging, payment fee), minus the ads spread across orders. The profit on added products depends on the attach rate, the share of orders that contain something besides the loss leader.
An example with made-up figures, excluding VAT:
Item Loss leader price in the campaign Value €19.90 Item Purchase cost Value €18.50 Item Margin on the loss leader Value €1.40 Item Orders that add other products Value 60% Item Profit from added products per order (60% x €44 x 40%) Value €10.56 Item Variable cost per order Value €6.00 Item Profit per order before ads Value €5.96 Item Campaign profit: 600 orders, €1,800 in ads Value €1,776 Item Usual offer: 420 orders x €7.44, minus €1,800 Value €1,325In the example the loss leader wins, but only just: if the attach rate drops below roughly 56%, the usual offer becomes more profitable. And an order with only the loss leader leaves you €1.40 margin minus €6 variable cost, a loss of €4.60. That's why the attach rate is the number I watch most closely. I described the other levers for basket size in average order value: 7 levers.
For the added products, the recommendations in the cart and on the product page matter a lot. I wrote about them in upsell and cross-sell in the cart.
The EU Unfair Commercial Practices Directive has a list of practices banned in all circumstances. One of them is bait advertising: inviting customers to buy a product at a specified price without disclosing that you have reasonable grounds to believe you won't be able to supply that product, or an equivalent one, at that price, for a reasonable period and in reasonable quantities, given the product, the scale of the advertising and the price. In Romania the rule sits in annex 1 of Law 363/2007, in Denmark in annex 1 of the Marketing Practices Act, and the other EU countries have their own versions.
In practice, this is what I do:
This is where countries differ, so check the rules in every market you sell to.
Romania. Government Ordinance 99/2000 on the marketing of products and services bans selling at a loss, defined as selling at a price equal to or below the purchase cost. There are exceptions, such as stock liquidations, seasonal clearance sales or goods that perish quickly, but promotional sales aren't among them: the law says explicitly that promotional sales must not be made at a loss. In the text I consulted, the fine for selling at a loss outside the exceptions is 2,000 to 10,000 lei. In practice, in Romania the loss leader has to stay above purchase cost, even by one leu.
Denmark. The Danish Consumer Ombudsman's price marketing guidelines I read don't deal with selling below cost, but they are strict about the stock reservation: it must be specific, placed next to the offer and clearly visible, for example "while stocks last" or "limited quantity". For companies with a dominant market position, competition law bans abuse of that position, and very low prices can fall under it.
If you present the loss leader as a discount, the prior price rule also applies: the lowest price in the last 30 days, explained in discounts and the lowest price in 30 days. All of this is general information: check your specific offer with your lawyer or accountant, including what counts as purchase cost.
Before a loss leader campaign, I work out the minimum attach rate with the client and compare it with what we see in orders from recent months. If the real rate is well below the threshold, we drop the idea. If it clears it, we prepare the stock, the per order limit, the complementary products on the page and the post campaign report.
Enter the loss leader's price and cost, what customers add to the basket and your usual offer; the calculator shows which one makes more profit and from what attach rate it pays off.
A loss leader is worth it only if the profit per basket beats your usual offer, with enough stock, a clear stock reservation next to the offer and, in countries like Romania, a price above purchase cost. Do the maths beforehand, watch the attach rate during the campaign and check the result afterwards. If you'd like to build your season offer together, see the eCommerce strategy page or write to me via contact.